“Few tragedies can be more extensive than the stunting of life”
When I read the news that student-worker Declan Sullivan died while filming a Notre Dame football practice, I started to tear up because it was such an avoidable accident. I wasn’t on site and I don’t know all the facts of the situation. However, it is clear to me that no one should have been 30 feet high on a video lift with 50 miles per hour winds.
For comparison sake, hurricane wind speeds are defined as those sustained at 75 miles per hour. Sadly, the student worker was aware of his perilous situation, tweeting before his death, “Gust of wind up to 60mph well today will be fun at work… I guess I’ve lived long enough :-/ [worried emoticon].” Less than an hour before the tragic fall he tweeted again, “Holy fuck holy fuck this is terrifying.”
Clearly this incident and his tragic death were completely avoidable and preventable. As a student-worker, Sullivan could not be to blame since he was simply doing his job. A young man in his position did not have the power to fight the stupidity of the decision to continue the filming of practice in such harsh conditions. Although some blame can be placed on the institution, administrators, and trainers charged with protecting the safety of those involved with the college’s sports, much of the blame has to be placed with the person leading the unsafe practice, head coach Brian Kelly.
Only a few people at Notre Dame know how the day unfolded, and many of them will remain tight-lipped. My opinion is that Brian Kelly decided his team needed to practice outside. Since the outside practices are always filmed on the video lift, Brian Kelly expected this practice to be filmed too. Despite the bad weather, Brian Kelly expected this practice to be filmed too. No one else, except Brian Kelly had the power to relieve the student worker of his job that day. As a former NCAA assistant coach, I can tell you with surety that the head coach becomes irate at any disagreement, even if rational and possibly life-saving advice.
I’ve despised Brian Kelly ever since his departure from the University of Cincinnati. On December 14, 2009 Kelly started his first day at Notre Dame, walking out on his old team only weeks before their bid for an undefeated season and outside chance at finishing the year with a number one ranking in the polls. It was clear that this move was completely selfish and that Brian Kelly did not care at all about the student-athletes he coached.
The move was audacious and showed that Kelly was a jerk (to put it mildly). Ben Guidugli, one of his former players at Cincinnati summed it up best, “It’s like somebody turned their back on us. We brought this whole thing this far. We’ve come this far. To have someone walk out now is disappointing.” It was evident that Brian Kelly was not setting a good example for the student-athletes he was put in charge of teaching. Although winning is important, an NCAA head coach is tasked with a more important duty: to help develop young people into adults with character. Brian Kelly failed his athletes by lacking character with his untimely departure.
I followed Brian Kelly closely when he coached his first few games at Notre Dame, mostly looking at his interaction with the student-athletes, as he already exhibited that the student-athletes and their development meant so little to him. Every week on the sidelines, television cameras caught him in verbal tirades. Screaming might be allowed in professional sports and the corporate world, but it has absolutely no place in college athletics.
His lips visibly pursed together curse word after curse word when his student-athletes made their way to the sideline after a mistake. Such behavior is completely unacceptable and inappropriate in the treatment of young men during their undergraduate education. While watching these outbursts, I called for his suspension. His actions on the sidelines again showed that he didn’t care at all how he treated his student-athletes; he only cared about his own success.
On October 27, 2010 it’s my opinion that Brian Kelly’s selfish desire to have practice and have it filmed in unsafe weather led to the tragic death of Declan Sullivan. I have seen too many NCAA coaches bully others. Watching Brian Kelly on the sidelines, he does not look approachable and from his other actions he only seems to care about himself. I ask for Notre Dame to investigate this incident and ask that they dismiss Brian Kelly if it is found that he contributed in any way to Sullivan’s death.
Brett Favre said years ago after his father’s death, “When you lose a family member or something tragic happens, that stays with you forever. You never get over it. Knowing that you have to deal with that for the rest of your life… Football is important, but not as important as you once thought it was.”
My thoughts and prayers are with Declan Sullivan’s friends and families. I’ll repeat… this was avoidable. Perhaps this is a chance to reevaluate NCAA procedures and the power wielded by these head coaches that don’t care about the safety and well-being of their student-athletes and employees. I am angered and saddened by this tragic accident. So it goes.
* this blog reflects an opinion of Kevin Semanick
Originally appeared on 10/27/2010


